Blog · Buying

APR vs. interest rate: which one should I compare on a mortgage?

House keys handed over above a stack of moving boxes

Short answer

Look at both. The interest rate is the price of borrowing the money, and it sets your monthly principal and interest. The APR (annual percentage rate) is that price plus the lender's up-front charges, such as points and origination fees, shown as one yearly number. A loan with a lower rate can still cost more if its fees are high, and the APR shows that. Because APR assumes you keep the loan for its full term, also weigh how long you will really keep it, and compare the monthly payment and total cost side by side.

What is the difference between the interest rate and the APR?

The interest rate is the price of borrowing the money. The APR is that price plus the charges you pay to get the loan, spread over the loan and shown as one yearly number. Federal law, the Truth in Lending Act and its Regulation Z, requires lenders to figure APR the same way, so it is the one number that lets you compare the full cost of credit from one lender to the next.

It gets confusing because both are percentages, they sit side by side on every quote, and your monthly payment is figured from the interest rate, not the APR. On a loan with no fees the two numbers are nearly the same, which makes people think they always are.

Tom's take: “APR is the more accurate picture of what a borrower is paying, because it counts the fees along with the interest.”

Here is a made-up example, not a rate quote: a loan with a 6.5% rate and an 8% APR is more expensive over its full term than a loan with a 7% rate and a 7.5% APR, even though the first one has the lower rate. The fees on the first loan are heavy enough to outweigh the lower rate.

How is APR figured?

APR starts with the amount financed: the loan amount minus the finance charges you pay at or before closing, such as points and origination fees. The APR is the yearly rate that makes your scheduled payments pay back that smaller amount. Because you are repaying the full loan amount but only had the use of the amount financed, the APR comes out higher than the interest rate whenever there are up-front charges.

Regulation Z sets out the math (the actuarial method in its Appendix J) and how exact the disclosure must be. On a regular fixed-rate loan, the APR you are shown has to be within 1/8 of a percentage point of the true figure; on some loans with irregular payments or advances, within 1/4. On page 5 of your Closing Disclosure, the Loan Calculations box shows the pieces: total of payments, finance charge, amount financed, APR and total interest percentage.

What goes into a mortgage APR, and what is left out?

The APR is built from the loan's finance charges, the costs you pay because you are borrowing. On a home loan, several common closing costs are left out on purpose because you would pay them in a cash sale too.

What counts in a mortgage APR
CostIn the APR?Why
InterestYesThe core finance charge
Discount pointsYesPaid to the lender to lower the rate
Origination, underwriting and processing feesYesCharged by the lender or broker to make the loan
Broker compensation the borrower paysYesA finance charge under Regulation Z
Broker compensation the lender paysYes, through the rateBuilt into the interest rate, not a separate fee
Mortgage insurance (FHA premiums, PMI)YesRequired as a condition of the loan
Prepaid interest from closing to month endYesInterest paid at closing
Lender creditsLower itThey offset charges you would otherwise pay
Appraisal, credit report, title insurance, document preparation and notary feesNoReal estate fees left out by 12 CFR 1026.4(c)(7)
Recording fees and transfer taxesNoGovernment fees you would pay in a cash sale or to record the mortgage
Property taxes and homeowners insuranceNoOwning costs, not costs of the credit
Late fees and returned-payment feesNoDepend on what happens after closing

Broker compensation is in the APR either way. If you pay the broker, it is a finance charge. If the lender pays the broker, that cost is built into the interest rate. Costs left out of the APR still appear in dollars on your Loan Estimate, so check them there. In New Hampshire, also budget for property taxes, which are not in the APR and can be a large part of the payment.

What doesn't the APR show?

APR already counts the interest and the up-front charges to get the loan. What it leaves out is everything that depends on what happens later.

  • How long you keep the loan. APR spreads the up-front charges over the full term. If you sell or refinance in a few years, those charges were spread over far fewer payments, so your real yearly cost was higher than the APR showed.
  • Fees that depend on you. APR assumes you pay on time, so late fees and returned-payment fees aren't in it. Most home loans you live in can't have a prepayment penalty, but some business purpose loans, like many investment property loans, can, and APR won't show it.
  • Future rate changes on an ARM. On an adjustable-rate loan, the APR assumes the index stays where it was at closing. It can't predict where the rate goes after the fixed period. See how an ARM works.
  • Total cost. A 30-year loan can have a similar APR to a 15-year loan and a lower payment, yet cost far more in total interest.

Tom's take: “I tell people to compare three numbers: APR, monthly payment, and total of all payments.”

The Loan Estimate makes this easier. Page 3 has a Comparisons box with what you will have paid in the first 5 years and how much of that went to principal, the APR, and the total interest percentage (TIP), which is the total interest over the life of the loan as a percentage of the loan amount. Use the 5-year figure when you expect to move or refinance, and the TIP when you expect to keep the loan a long time.

Should I pay points for a lower rate, or take the rate with no points?

Every loan has a range of rate options for the same day. The par rate is the one with no points and no lender credit. Below par, you pay discount points up front to buy the rate down; one point is 1% of the loan amount. Above par, you take a slightly higher rate and the lender gives you a lender credit toward your closing costs. Points raise the APR, and lender credits lower it.

Tom's take: “It comes down to how long you will really keep the loan. If you pay the loan off early, you never get that fee back, so the no-fee loan often wins. If you will carry the loan for the full term, the lower rate has time to make up for the fee.”

To find the break-even point, divide the cost of the points by how much they lower your monthly payment. Here is a made-up example in round numbers: if points cost $4,000 and lower the payment by $100 a month, it takes 40 months, a little over three years, to earn the cost back. Sell or refinance before then, and the points cost you money.

Tom's take: “I see this choice every day. In my experience it often takes around three years of lower payments to earn that cost back compared with the par rate. When rates are elevated and there is a good chance you will refinance within a couple of years, you may never reach that break-even point, so I usually recommend against paying for the lower rate. Sometimes it even makes more sense to take a slightly higher rate and get a credit toward your costs.”

See how lender credits work and seller credits and rate buydowns, which can pay for points with the seller's money instead of yours.

How big a gap between the rate and the APR is too big?

There is no legal cutoff, and the gap depends on the loan amount, the term and the program. A smaller loan shows a bigger gap for the same dollar fees, because the fees are a larger share of what you borrowed.

Tom's take: “I look at the gap between the interest rate and the APR more than at one cutoff number. In my experience, when the APR is more than about 1% higher than the interest rate, that's the point to stop and ask what is in it. A gap that wide means there are a lot of fees built into the loan.”

Two common reasons a wide gap can be expected:

  • You chose to buy the rate down. The points you pay push the APR up on purpose.
  • The loan has mortgage insurance. FHA premiums and private mortgage insurance are finance charges, so they widen the gap too.

Either way, ask the lender to explain every charge in section A of page 2 of the Loan Estimate, Origination Charges, and any mortgage insurance on page 1.

How do I compare two mortgage offers fairly?

  1. Get Loan Estimates on the same day. Rates change daily, so offers from different days don't line up.
  2. Match the loan. Same loan amount, program, term and rate lock length, so you are comparing price, not a different loan.
  3. Match the points. Compare par to par, or the same points to the same points. Otherwise the lower rate may just be the one you are paying more for.
  4. Compare the APR to see which loan costs less over the full term.
  5. Compare the 5-year figure on page 3 if you may move or refinance.
  6. Compare the monthly payment with taxes and insurance, from the Projected Payments table on page 1, to make sure it fits your budget.

Federal rules also protect you near the finish line. If the APR on your Closing Disclosure goes up by more than the allowed tolerance, or the loan product changes, or a prepayment penalty is added, the lender must give you a corrected Closing Disclosure and wait 3 more business days before closing. Advertising follows the same idea: an ad that states an interest rate has to state the APR too.

What helps my rate in the weeks before I apply?

Your credit score is one of the biggest pieces of mortgage pricing, and some of it can move quickly.

Tom's take: “Paying down credit card balances is the fastest step, because how much of your limits you are using can change your score as soon as the new balances report. You don't need to pay every card to zero, though. I have seen people do that and watch their score dip, because the scoring models like to see a little activity. A good rule of thumb is to keep each card at around 10% of its limit or less.”

  • Check your credit reports for errors at AnnualCreditReport.com, the free site set up under federal law, and dispute anything wrong with the credit bureau.
  • Don't open new accounts or finance a car or furniture before you close. New debt can change both your score and how much you qualify for.
  • Shop in a short window. Credit scoring models count mortgage inquiries within a shopping window as one inquiry; the credit guide explains how.
  • Ask about a rapid rescore. If you pay down a balance after your credit is pulled, a lender can often ask the credit bureaus to update it so your new score can be used.
  • Consider the term. A 15-year loan is usually priced lower than a 30-year loan, with a higher monthly payment.

Does adding a co-borrower with better credit lower my rate?

Usually not the way people expect. Each borrower's middle score is taken from their three credit reports, one from each bureau.

Tom's take: “With the mortgage lenders I work with, we have to use the lower of the two borrowers' middle credit scores. So if one borrower's middle score is 650 and the co-borrower's is 750, the loan is priced at 650.”

Those scores are a made-up example. What a co-borrower adds is income and savings, which can help you qualify for the loan amount you need. Rules differ by loan program and lender, so ask before you add someone. See co-borrowers and co-signers.

What are the red flags on a mortgage offer?

  • A big fee before you get a Loan Estimate. Under federal rules, a lender can charge only a reasonable credit report fee until you have the Loan Estimate and say you want to go ahead.
  • "Guaranteed approval" before anyone has looked at your income or credit.
  • Pressure to sign today, or to lock before you have seen the costs in writing.
  • No Loan Estimate. A lender who won't put the rate, APR and costs in writing on the standard form.
  • No license. Every mortgage loan officer and company has an NMLS number. You can look them up for free on NMLS Consumer Access.

Does APR work the same way on a personal loan?

Yes. The same Truth in Lending rules apply, so a personal loan's APR also counts the interest and the up-front fees. The difference is how the fee is usually paid. On many personal loans the origination fee comes out of the money you receive instead of being paid at a closing table.

Tom's take: “Check how much cash actually lands in your account. If you need $10,000 and the fee is taken out of it, you may have to borrow more to cover it.”

The rest of this page carries over: weigh how long you will keep the loan before paying more up front, treat a big gap between the rate and the APR as a reason to ask for every fee in writing, and ask each lender how it treats a co-borrower's score, since personal loan lenders each set their own rules.

Can someone look over the offer I already have?

Yes. A free Loan Estimate second look goes through the rate, APR, points and fees with you and shows where they come from. Tom MacDonald, Loan Officer, NMLS #2748687, compares pricing for your exact loan from the 45 lenders Elite Mortgage Group NMLS #2502308MBR works with, on the same day, so the offers line up.

General information only, not tax or legal advice. Program availability, eligibility and terms vary by lender and are subject to change and to underwriting approval. Not a commitment to lend.

Have a question about your plans?

Tom is happy to talk it through. No cost, no obligation and no credit pull to start.

Call or text

Reach Tom directly on his cell.

603-851-4982

Get a call back

A few quick questions, then Tom calls you.

Apply online

Start Elite's secure application anytime.

Start my application